Sometimes I think I may have been a real sick in the mud when it comes to laptop computing in my district. Its not that I don't believe in the concept - just that our ability to execute has always been marginal at best. "Shared" computers often get treated like shared textbooks - no one takes ownership over them and then end up getting treated pretty awfully. This is true of any shared computing environment (consider your "swing" labs where there is no teacher who looks out for it.. what shape is in in come May?) but is especially evident with mobile labs where there is so much more that can (and will) go wrong.
In thinking about how to try 1:1 more effectively, I've been rethinking the idea of mobile labs as being the ideal environment for cross-curricular use. In the past, we have used laptop carts as a way of "bringing the technology to the classroom"for teachers in diverse subject areas that often don't have access to a lab, presumably because "computer" course are scheduled in there. The fault in this has been that we are giving the most tentative and temperamental tools to those who often have the least tolerance for failure (a geography teacher has a hard time of thinking about troubleshooting wireless connections as a "teachable moment"). Combine this with the fact that the carts are shared, and you have a recipe for failure in many cases.
So in rethinking, why not put the laptops with the teachers/students where they are most likely to struggle through the learning curve (say, in our BTT1O courses - a bread and butter computer course in our district) and get them out of the labs. This has the effect of freeing up reliable labs for other curriculum areas, and also can help break up the pedagogy in BTT from being a pure "applications" type course and refocus on the business aspects of the curriculum.
One approach we are considering is a 1;1 laptop program where the BTT students in out test school would be assigned a personal laptop for the entire semester. It would be theirs to take home/bring to other classes right up until they finish the course. Buying 2 or 3 class sets of 'netbooks (considering the new revision of the Intel Classmate, likely with Windows, but who knows,,,) isn't over the top expensive - especially when you consider that it frees up a lab in the school.
Still just hashing the idea around, but I'd love to hear if any of this rings true to your own laptop experiences...
Keywords: laptops, mobile labs